A-One Steels shares make decent market debut at 14% premium on BSE; should you buy, sell or hold?

Reports coming in for today mention that A-One Steels shares made a decent market debut on Thursday, following an 11.61-times subscription to its initial public offering (IPO) between September 24 and 28 in the primary market.
Shares of A-One Steels India Ltd. were listed at Rs 455 per share on the NSE, a premium of 12.34 percent. The Rs 405-crore offering had a price range of Rs 385-405 per share.
On the BSE, the shares of the firm were listed at Rs 462 per share, a premium of more than 14 percent. The firm's market capitalisation post stock-exchange debut of its shares stood at Rs 3,336.54-crore.
A-One Steels marker debut was almost at par with expectations in grey market, which had anticipated a stock-exchange debut gain of around 14 percent.
A-One Steels share stock-exchange debut today: Should you buy, sell or hold?
Mahesh M. Ojha, Vice President Research & Business Development at Kantilal Chagganlal Securities, stated "A-One Steels India operates an integrated and diversified steel manufacturing business, with capabilities spanning sponge iron, billets and downstream long and flat steel products, supported by six manufacturing facilities across Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh. The firm’s captive consumption model enhances integration across the value chain, while its diversified product portfolio caters to construction, infrastructure and industrial applications."
"Profitability has strengthened meaningfully, with EBITDA margin improving to 7.29% in FY26 from 4.91% in FY25, while PAT rose to Rs 127.4 crore. At around 24.55x post-offering FY26 P/E and 13.55x EV/EBITDA, valuations appear broadly aligned with industry benchmarks, although sustaining margin improvement stays important given the cyclical nature of the steel industry. The proposed Rs 250 crore debt repayment/prepayment should backing balance-sheet deleveraging and strengthen financial flexibility. Firm is supported by earnings recovery, backward integration, manufacturing scale and scheduled debt reduction. Allotted market participants with a long-term perspective may HOLD, while short- to medium-term market participants may consider booking partial upside around stock-exchange debut," he further noted.
Sarvam Goel, Founder – Pocketful, noted "Valuations look reasonable, though past profitability has been volatile given swings in steel prices, and demand for the offering was moderate, subscribed 12x."
Earlier, it boosted Rs 120.90 crore from anchor market participants.
Of the net proceeds from the fresh offering, Rs 250 crore will be used for pre-payment or partial repayment of certain outstanding borrowings, while the remaining funds will be utilised for general corporate purposes.
Bengaluru-headquartered A-One Steels India is a backward/vertically integrated steel manufacturer with operations spanning sponge iron, MS billets and finished steel products such as TMT bars, HR and CR coils, MS pipes, CR pipes and galvanised pipes and tubes.
The firm additionally manufactures industrial products including met coke and ferro alloys.